News & Article


Why Managers Should Become Coaches: Lessons from John Whitmore

John

August 11-2025

By: Dhania Puspa

In today’s fast-paced business world, the role of a manager goes beyond simply giving instructions. According to John Whitmore, a pioneer of modern coaching and author of Coaching for Performance, managers must become coaches to elevate the performance of individuals and teams to a higher level.

This approach is rooted in the belief that coaching in leadership is one of the most effective ways to:

  • Improve performance
  • Develop potential
  • Achieve organizational goals sustainably

This article will discuss who John Whitmore is, the strong reasons why the role of a manager as a coach is crucial, the differences between coaching and traditional management, as well as practical steps to build a coaching culture within an organization.

Getting to Know John Whitmore and His Coaching Philosophy

Sir John Whitmore (1937–2017) was a key figure in the coaching world and the creator of the GROW model (Goal, Reality, Options, Will). His book Coaching for Performance has become a global reference for leaders, HR professionals, and human development practitioners.

His philosophy is simple yet revolutionary:

“Coaching is unlocking a person’s potential to maximize their performance. It is helping them learn, not teaching them.”

Whitmore believed that leadership through coaching not only improves work results but also shapes individuals to be independent, creative, and responsible.

Why Managers Should Become Coaches

  1. Enhancing Team Performance
    Coaching involves team members in finding their own solutions. This sense of ownership makes them more motivated.
  2. Developing Individual Potential
    Coaching helps managers recognize the strengths and areas for development of each team member.
  3. Strengthening Work Relationships
    The role of the manager as a coach encourages more open and empathetic two-way communication.
  4. Fostering a Learning Culture
    A coaching culture creates a work environment that views challenges as opportunities to learn.
  5. Increasing Organizational Adaptability
    Teams guided by coaching are better prepared to make critical decisions.

Coaching vs. Traditional Management

Aspect

Traditional Management

Coaching Leadership

Main Focus

Task and result control

Long-term performance & potential development

Communication Style

One-way (command and control)

Two-way, question-based

Decision Making

Centralized with the manager

Collaborative with the team

Long-Term Impact

Short-term compliance

Sustainable motivation and commitment

How to Be an Active Manager-Coach

  1. Practice Questioning Skills
    Use open-ended questions such as:
  • “What do you want to achieve?”
  • “What obstacles are you facing?”
  • “What options have you considered?”
  1. Provide Constructive Feedback
    Use feedforward by focusing on future solutions.
  2. Listen Actively
    Understand not only words but also body language and emotions.
  3. Build Trust
    Create a safe space for discussion and learning.
  4. Use the GROW Model
  • G – Goal: Define the objective
  • R – Reality: Analyse the current situation
  • O – Options: Explore alternatives
  • W – Will: Commit to actions

John Whitmore emphasized that managers who act as coaches are strategic assets to their organizations. Through coaching, managers not only lead but also nurture the human potential behind performance.

Challenges in Implementing Coaching

  • Time Constraints: Integrate coaching into daily conversations.
  • Old Mindsets: Participate in training and mentoring.
  • Team Resistance: Build trust by demonstrating tangible benefits.

Long-Term Benefits of a Coaching Culture

  • Increased productivity
  • Higher employee retention
  • More frequent innovation
  • More confident and independent employees
  • A healthy and collaborative work culture

Enhance your coaching skills to lead more effectively.
Join the training program with the expert team at Qando Qoaching and experience a transformation in your leadership.

📍 campsite.bio/qqgroup
📲 Follow Qando Qoaching on social media for tips and training updates.

Mari Bersama Melangkah Menuju Indonesia Hebat!

en_US